Thursday, August 27, 2009

Good to recap on the basics

Wealth of Nations (1776) excerpt

By Adam Smith

There are three orders in society - those who live by rent, by labour and by profits. Employers constitute the third order. . . The proposal of any new law by or regulation which comes from this order ought always to be listened to with the greatest precaution and ought never to be adopted till after having been long and carefully examined, not only with the most scrupulous but with the most suspicious attention. It comes from an order of men whose interest is never exactly the same with that of the public, who have generally an interest to deceive and even oppress the public. . .

Masters are always and everywhere in a sort of tacit but constant and uniform combination not to raise the wages of workers. . . . Masters. . .sometimes enter into particular combinations to sink the level of wages. . . These are always conducted with the utmost silence and secrecy. . .

Wherever there is great property there is great inequality. Civil government, so far as it is instituted for the security of property, is in reality, instituted for the defence of the rich against the poor, or of those who have some property against those who have none at all. . .

Perfect liberty can never happen if government heeds or is entrusted to the mean rapacity, the monopolizing spirit of merchants and manufacturers who neither are, nor ought to be the rulers of mankind.

Thursday, July 30, 2009

A roundabout way to say "I"

The Skeleton in the Cupboard
From the series - Yes Miister
(a persoal favourite)

Sir Humphrey: "Minister, I think there is something you perhaps ought to know."
Jim Hacker: "Yes Humphrey?"
Sir Humphrey: "The identity of the Official whose alleged responsibility for this hypothetical oversight has been the subject of recent discussion, is NOT shrouded in quite such impenetrable obscurity as certain previous disclosures may have led you to assume, but not to put too fine a point on it, the individual in question is, it may surprise you to learn, one whom you present interlocutor is in the habit of defining by means of the perpendicular pronoun."
Jim Hacker: "I beg your pardon?"
Sir Humphrey: "It was...I."

(what a roundabout way to say "I")

Thursday, June 18, 2009

Beat the cartel, join the market

Fe-Indicus policy series



One of the tragedies of unreformed agriculture is that the producer, the trader and the end buyer are all at a disadvantage during transactions. Farmers are at the mercy of the local trading cartel. Traders are forced to deal with undifferentiated products (undifferentiated by quality) and have no incentive to add value. Buyers are left with a wide variety of undifferentiated products. The whole process adds to costs and wastage that everyone in the chain ends up paying for. One solution is a system of scientific warehousing, tradeable warehouse receipts (WR) and markets dealing with WRs.

In order to understand the role of the WR, let us first look at issues from the perspective of a small producer. What would you want if you were a small farmer with 6-7 acres of land?

Remember, you have taken credit to buy seeds, fertilisers, pay for irrigation, etc, but you can pay this back only after the produce is sold. Your main problem is to sell in a market that is some distance away. Having carried the produce to the market, you are in no position to take it back and so you are forced to sell at whatever price the trading cartel is giving at that point in time. This is even more the case while selling perishables.

What you would like is to have a warehouse within 10-15 km of your farm. You get the produce graded and certified and stored there and get a warehouse receipt, which clearly specifies what you delivered. With the WR, a transferable, tradeable and fully-negotiable instrument, you have the option of holding the WR, selling it or pledging it for loan. By increasing your stock holding capacity, you can wait for a better price or sell instantly—in short you have more choice. No longer are you at the mercy of a local cartel.

Current markets involve physical trading of agricultural goods with no system of grading. Being dependent on visual inspection, this can be easily manipulated by local cartels. Further, without grading and sorting, there is a loss of value as all grades get clubbed into a uniform ‘fair average quality’.

A critical component of such a system is accredited warehousing that stakeholders trust, that provides storage and assaying services. Obviously, this requires regulatory measures.

While considerable capacity augmentation is needed, this must involve change in warehousing standards. Current storage is unscientific, individual owned and mostly unlicensed; the quality of commodities stored and preservation techniques are abysmally poor. For small farmers to benefit, we estimate a requirement of 10,000 to 40,000 warehouses depending on the desired radius of operation (10 km or 5 km). While existing warehouses can be upgraded, and government figures suggest that nearly 4,000 private warehouses exist, in reality very few have scientific storage systems. Majority of warehousing receipts do not enjoy the fiduciary trust of depositors and banks.

There are two key issues here—accredited bankable chains of warehouses need to be created and warehouse receipts need to be fully negotiable instruments. This is necessary to create a marketplace that is fair to all. Trading with WRs in the markets (with the faith that the specifications will be delivered) makes trade highly liquid and allows wider participation. One can imagine buyers from far away participating in trade, without a direct transaction with the producer. WRs can take the demat form, injecting further liquidity into the system.

This would be a paradigm shift in marketing. Organisations like National Spot Exchange and NCDEX Spot exchange are already working towards this change. Note these spot markets are qualitatively different from the existing Agricultural Produce Marketing Committee (APMC) markets since they separate grading and storing from pure price transactions. They need to be supported by regulatory measures and incentives and the APMC markets need to be reformed so that they enable similar WR-based trading.

The Warehousing Development and Regulation Act, passed in 2007, was scheduled for notification in March, but no regulator has been appointed yet. This Act provides the legal backing for WRs. Meanwhile, despite the delay, the National Bulk Holding Corporation has reportedly tied up with more than 30 banks to offer loans to about 45,000 farmers against its warehouse receipts. Clearly, the forces for change cannot be held back any longer.


Amit Sinha is president at Indicus Analytics. Email: amit.sinha@indicus.net

Monday, September 29, 2008

Is there a clear relationship between credit growth and market growth?

The fastest growing cities out of 112 top cities of India

 

Growth rates (CAGR)

Market Size Growth Rate

Deposit Growth Rate

Credit Growth Rate

Silvassa

23

14

71

Gandhinagar

22

10

54

Bokaro

19

7

-4

Surat

17

11

18

Thiruvallur

17

11

28

Agartala

16

13

32

Chandigarh

16

13

7

Thanjavur

16

5

20

Kohima

15

9

26

Noida

15

28

43

The slowest growing cities out of 112 top cities of India

 

Growth rates (CAGR)

Market Size Growth Rate

Deposit Growth Rate

Credit Growth Rate

Guntur

8

7

16

Gwalior

8

6

9

Jabalpur

8

3

0

Nellore

8

7

22

Varanasi

8

6

13

Kanpur

7

7

13

Kavaratti

7

 

 

Vijayawada

7

7

24

Dhanbad

6

12

15

Kancheepuram

2

16

22

With the exception of Bokaro, and to a certain extent Chandigarh, the 10 fastest growing cities grew on the back of high credit growth. However, this is not a general rule as a look at the slower growing cities reveal. Cities such as Vijaywada, Kancheepuram, Nellore and Guntur did not display a robust growth in spite of high credit growth. Deposit growth, on the other hand is an effect of market growth and in general grows in the wake of market growth. This is generally borne out by the facts, though a few notable exceptions exist – Thanjavur, Kohima, Bokaro (among the fast growing cities) and Dhanbad and Kancheepuram (slow growing cities)

data source: Indicus Analytics

Friday, September 26, 2008

The Double Tragedy of Bihar

It has been some time since the massive floods ravaged Bihar. Already it has disappeared from the front pages and the main media. That the disaster affected over 3 million people is a monumental tragedy. The second tragedy is more insidious – that these people do not matter. That is the reason it has receded from the front pages. The media and the people are merely confirming the facts. The facts are grim – the region affected does not matter on the economic map of the country. That is the second tragedy, one that has insidiously occurred over the last 60 years.

The key affected districts are – Araria, Madhepura, Purnea, Saharsa and Supaul. Some of these regions have had high profile representation in the political space too. These districts are extremely backward and hence agriculture is the mainstay (other sectors are virtually absent). The share of agriculture in the GDP of these districts is 44% (the All India share of agriculture is 19% and in Bihar it is nearly 30%). Other grim facts:

The total economy of these affected districts is so small that it is fair to say that they just about exist on the economic landscape. This is the bigger tragedy. These guys don't seem to matter.

"Does it take much of a man to see his whole life go down, To look up on the world from a hole in the ground, To wait for your future like a horse that's gone lame, To lie in the gutter and die with no name?

Only a hobo, but one more is gone, Leavin' nobody to sing his sad song, Leavin' nobody to carry him home, Only a hobo, but one more is gone"


Tuesday, July 29, 2008

Shaken, not stirred - Moribund

Unexpected defeat can shake a person or an organization so badly that hysterical and irrational reactions start appearing. These are expected to subside after a while. What do you say when it shows no sign of abating? Can the organization be said to be completely derailed with little hope of recovery?
The ruling party in India was complacent in 2004. It was so sure of a thunping win that it ordered elections a year ahead of schedule. The media, and its main opposition also seemed to agree. the end result was a shocker. They lost. Then followed a series of hysterical rabble rousing about a foreigner becoming the prime minister.
Over time the party kept shooting itself in the foot. The main leaders were pronounced as past their prime by the ideological backbone and for a while they went on the backfoot..........only to return as the prime ministerial candidates! While the world changed, nothing changed here, including the sulk. The confidence vote was another opportunity to get back into the forefront. This was lost, again very badly - first the centre of gravity shifted away to Mayawati and then the vote itself was lost. One expected more hysterics. But I doubt if anyone would have anticipated that senior people from the party would start linking the bomb blasts to the confidence vote.
Either they have completely lost it, or they believe that people are idiots and anything goes. I am inclined to think that it is the former.